VR simulation vs manikins
The short verdict
Manikins are still the best way to practise hands-on skills like compression depth, ventilation and airway. VR is better for repetition, decision-making, team roles and rare events, because it needs no room setup and resets in seconds.
The strongest programs use both. Research on mixed simulation suggests the order matters too.
Last checked 12 November 2026. Spot something out of date? Tell us and we will fix it.
Firsthand XR product render. We do not show other vendors’ products or logos.
Where manikin simulation is strong
- Manikins give real tactile feedback that headsets cannot.
- High-fidelity manikins are established in sim labs, with trained staff and proven workflows.
- Our own debrief marks compression depth as needing a manikin.
Side by side
| Feature | Manikin simulation | Firsthand XR |
|---|---|---|
| Hands-on skills | Strong. Real compressions, bag-valve-mask and airway handling. | Rehearses the sequence and timing. Compression depth still needs a manikin. |
| Setup and reset | Room, technician and moulage. Reset takes time. | Put the headset on. Reset in seconds. |
| Repetitions per learner | Limited by room and staff time. | As many as the learner wants. |
| Environment | The sim lab, dressed to look like a ward. | Wards, birth suites, switchrooms, workshops and patrol bases. |
| Patient response | Controlled by the operator or a programmed scenario. | Live patient engine responds to the trainee’s actions. |
| Scoring | Depends on the observer and the debrief. | Every action timed and scored, with a consistent debrief. |
| Team practice | Strong in the same room. | Team sessions with roles on the same network. |
Choose manikin simulation if
- You are assessing psychomotor skills: compressions, ventilation, airway, cannulation.
- You have a sim lab with staff time to run it.
Choose Firsthand XR if
- You need more repetitions per learner than the lab can give.
- You want rare events and different settings without building them.
- You want consistent scoring and debriefs across a large cohort.
- You want a hybrid: VR first for thinking, manikin second for hands.
Questions people ask
Does VR replace manikins?
No. Use VR to rehearse decisions, sequence and teamwork, and manikins to practise and assess hands-on skills.
What order works best?
In a 2022 crossover study of nursing students, doing virtual simulation first and high-fidelity simulation second led to higher reflective thinking and self-confidence scores than the reverse order. It was a small study using screen-based virtual simulation, so treat it as a useful signal, not a rule.
Can I use mixed reality with a manikin?
Yes. Passthrough mode lets trainees see the real room, so you can combine headset scenarios with physical equipment.
Sources
- Park, Hur and Chung (2022), Learning effects of virtual versus high-fidelity simulations in nursing students: a crossover comparison. BMC Nursing 21:100 (via PubMed)
- NCSBN, National Simulation Study
Product and company names are trademarks of their owners and are used only to identify their products. This page is our own comparison and is not endorsed by any company named. Information about other products is taken from their public websites on the date shown and may have changed.
See it in a headset
Book a 30-minute demo. We will run a scenario live, talk through your training units and scope a pilot that fits your team.
